Auto insurance industry takes the gas money savings from small car owners
Filed under: Insurance, Transportation
An examination of automobile insurance premiums from The Wall Street Journal reveals that the nature of smaller autos makes them justifiably more expensive to insure. For some smaller cars, such as some of the new hybrid models, replacement parts can be difficult to obtain, and labor costs are sometimes higher than for conventional autos. Additionally, hybrid cars can often take longer to repair.
Hybrids in the News
The BMW Concept 7 Series active hybrid car is seen on the back of a camera display at the Paris Auto Show, in Paris, Wednesday, Oct. 15, 2008. (AP Photo/Remy de la Mauviniere)
AP
People are seen looking at the BMW Concept 7 Series active hybrid car at the Paris Auto Show, in Paris, Wednesday, Oct. 15, 2008. (AP Photo/Remy de la Mauviniere)
AP
SHENZHEN, CHINA - OCTOBER 14: (CHINA OUT) Visitors view a F3DM electric vehicle and its model at 2008 China High-tech Fair (CHTF) on October 14, 2008 in Shenzhen of Guangdong Province, China. BYD F3DM, which has been claimed as China's first mass-produced electric vehicle by BYD Auto, is a gasoline-electric hybrid plug-in vehicle, using a small gasoline combustion engine to charge the car's battery. When fully charged, it can run as far as 100 to 110 kilometers by electricity. BYD planned to launch F3DM hybrid by the end of this year in Shenzhen. (Photo by China Photos/Getty Images)
Getty Images
SHENZHEN, CHINA - OCTOBER 14: (CHINA OUT) Visitors view a F3DM electric vehicle and its model at 2008 China High-tech Fair (CHTF) on October 14, 2008 in Shenzhen of Guangdong Province, China. BYD F3DM, which has been claimed as China's first mass-produced electric vehicle by BYD Auto, is a gasoline-electric hybrid plug-in vehicle, using a small gasoline combustion engine to charge the car's battery. When fully charged, it can run as far as 100 to 110 kilometers by electricity. BYD planned to launch F3DM hybrid by the end of this year in Shenzhen. (Photo by China Photos/Getty Images)
Getty Images
SHENZHEN, CHINA - OCTOBER 14: (CHINA OUT) A model poses to promote a BYD F0 at 2008 China High-tech Fair (CHTF) on October 14, 2008 in Shenzhen of Guangdong Province, China. F0, a traditional gasoline-fueled car, will be replaced by a Dual Mode (DM) plug-in hybrid in the future. BYD Auto unveiled on October 12 the F3DM, which has been claimed as China's first mass-produced electric vehicle by BYD. F3DM is a gasoline-electric hybrid plug-in vehicle, using a small gasoline combustion engine to charge the car's battery. When fully charged, it can run as far as 100 to 110 kilometers by electricity. BYD planned to launch F3DM hybrid by the end of this year in Shenzhen. (Photo by China Photos/Getty Images)
Getty Images
SHENZHEN, CHINA - OCTOBER 14: (CHINA OUT) A model pets a child as she poses to promote the BYD autos at 2008 China High-tech Fair (CHTF) on October 14, 2008 in Shenzhen of Guangdong Province, China. BYD Auto unveiled on October 12 the F3DM, which has been claimed as China's first mass-produced electric vehicle by BYD. F3DM is a gasoline-electric hybrid plug-in vehicle, using a small gasoline combustion engine to charge the car's battery. When fully charged, it can run as far as 100 to 110 kilometers by electricity. BYD planned to launch F3DM hybrid by the end of this year in Shenzhen. (Photo by China Photos/Getty Images)
Getty Images
SHENZHEN, CHINA - OCTOBER 14: (CHINA OUT) Visitors view a F3DM electric vehicle at 2008 China High-tech Fair (CHTF) on October 14, 2008 in Shenzhen of Guangdong Province, China. BYD F3DM, which has been claimed as China's first mass-produced electric vehicle by BYD Auto, is a gasoline-electric hybrid plug-in vehicle, using a small gasoline combustion engine to charge the car's battery. When fully charged, it can run as far as 100 to 110 kilometers by electricity. BYD planned to launch F3DM hybrid by the end of this year in Shenzhen. (Photo by China Photos/Getty Images)
Getty Images
SHENZHEN, CHINA - OCTOBER 14: (CHINA OUT) Visitors view a car model depicting the structure of F3DM electric vehicle at 2008 China High-tech Fair (CHTF) on October 14, 2008 in Shenzhen of Guangdong Province, China. BYD F3DM, which has been claimed as China's first mass-produced electric vehicle by BYD Auto, is a gasoline-electric hybrid plug-in vehicle, using a small gasoline combustion engine to charge the car's battery. When fully charged, it can run as far as 100 to 110 kilometers by electricity. BYD planned to launch F3DM hybrid by the end of this year in Shenzhen. (Photo by China Photos/Getty Images)
Getty Images
SHENZHEN, CHINA - OCTOBER 14: (CHINA OUT) The Household Charge Port and Quick Charge Port are seen on a F3DM electric vehicle at 2008 China High-tech Fair (CHTF) on October 14, 2008 in Shenzhen of Guangdong Province, China. BYD F3DM, which has been claimed as China's first mass-produced electric vehicle by BYD Auto, is a gasoline-electric hybrid plug-in vehicle, using a small gasoline combustion engine to charge the car's battery. When fully charged, it can run as far as 100 to 110 kilometers by electricity. BYD planned to launch F3DM hybrid by the end of this year in Shenzhen. (Photo by China Photos/Getty Images)
Getty Images
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA - OCTOBER 09: The Toyota Hybrid Supra HV-R is unveiled during the Australian International Motorshow at the Sydney Convention & Exhibition Centre October 9, 2008 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)
Getty Images
Karen Block, an independent insurance agent in Medford Wisconsin, indicates that the situation is quite basic and easy to understand. She stated: "Smaller cars have statistically higher repair costs." The Wall Street Journal article reports: "A recent study by the Highway Loss Data Institute, an affiliate of the IIHS, found that overall insurance costs for crash damage were higher for 11 of 12 hybrid cars and SUVs than for their gas-only counterparts."
While the owners of smaller cars may be paying higher costs to have their own cars repaired, it should be noted that their premiums for property damage liability may be lower. This is due to the fact that, when compared to larger vehicles in similar collisions, smaller cars tend to do less damage to the things they hit. There is concern however, that this condition may also mean that smaller cars offer their occupants a reduced level of crash protection, which is why I keep myself surrounded by a full sized Chevy pick-up truck, and keep my wife in her well built Jeep SUV.
When I went to book a rental car for a family vacation up to the Adirondacks yesterday, I was surprised to find SUVs renting for less than small cars. 
Fuel efficiency has quickly become the most important factor for many people exploring car purchases, but it may not be as simple as we thought. A car that gets 34 miles per gallon is more fuel efficient than one that gets 32, but it's hardly worth upgrading, right? Well, maybe not.
Maybe the airlines are starting to learn something about their cost-cutting measures and price hiking: customers don't like it. At least, it looks like a 
Earlier this week I 
The last time the United States faced a gas crisis, Europe and Japan provided the solution. While America's big auto producers were busy churning out eight-mile-to-the-gallon behemoths, Volkswagen, Toyota, and Honda undercut them with zippy little compact cars that went a lot further on a tank of gas. 
