Don't get caught up in a discount health scam
Filed under: Insurance, Fraud, Identity Theft, Insurance - Health Insurance
As millions of people lose their employer-based health insurance after being laid off, they seek desperately to find affordable health coverage. Unfortunately many people get caught up in discount heath schemes rather than real health insurance coverage.California is taking the lead on cracking down on these discount health and dental plan frauds with a plan to seek new licensing regulations. Right now in California, consumers have lodged complaints against more than 150 unlicensed discount health and dental plans over the last four years. State regulators want to rein in these plans that officials say frequently overstate benefits, offer little if any savings and promise access to doctors who aren't part of the system.
Not all discount plans are bad. California state officials identified two major health insurers with units in California, for instance, that have not been the subject of any consumer complaints to state regulators. The two -- Vital Savings, a product of Aetna, and OptumHealth Allies, an arm of UnitedHealth Group -- do not offer insurance but provide access to discount services to thousands of members.
So considering a discount plan is not necessarily a bad thing, but be sure you understand the difference. Discount plans are not health insurance. They only offer a discount if you use the physicians or other medical facilities that are part of the plan. One of the biggest problems I've found with these discount cards is that most physicians do not accept the plan and that a list of physicians provided by the plan often is not up to date. If you can't afford health insurance and are considering a discount plan instead, get a list of providers and call them those you may want to use to be sure they recognize and still accept the plan before you sign up.
Basically these discount health plans offer people who pay a monthly fee discounts on physician visits, hospital stays, prescription drugs, dental work, eyecare and other treatment. If they are legitimate you can find valuable money-saving benefits if you're not able to get or cannot afford health insurance. But, be sure you understand they are not health insurance. You will be obligated to pay all medical bills yourself.
Often the scammers lure you with ads that make it sound like they are selling real insurance or they make grossly inflated promises about savings and benefits. Many of these cards can cost you more than they are worth. Since they are not insurance, few states offer consumer protections and most don't require any licensing or healthcare background
If you do have coverage currently, don't cancel it until you've read all the fine print of any new health insurance or discount contract. You actually could end up canceling current health coverage by mistake because you think you found a better deal and end up with no health coverage at all. Often you won't find out until you're stuck with a large medical bill that you must pay out of your own pocket. Or you may find out when you present the discount card at your doctor's office and he gives you the bad news that this discount card is not health insurance.
Even if you find out that the discounts are legitimate, you may find out there are hidden administrative fees and other hidden costs that can eat up your discounts and you're stuck paying more than you thought when reading the glossy brochure. You could find the medical providers and treatments listed were just a come on and don't really exist. Always make a few calls to the promised providers to find out if the discounts are real before you sign up.
The discount card scammers use some common sales pitches:
- "Save up to 60% on health care" -- remember "up to" is an empty promise that might only apply to one provider's discount while all other providers offer discounts of 5% to 20%.
- "Affordable health coverage," which makes people think it's really health insurance, but it's not. You can only tell the difference by reading the fine print.
- "Guaranteed" benefits. Also makes it sound like insurance, but find out what exactly is being guaranteed.
- "Long-term care" discounts, be sure you understand this is not long-term healthcare insurance.
Credit card fraud can also be part of a discount card scam. The scammers will ask for your credit card or checking account number and then use it for identity theft schemes. Don't ever give your information over the phone or on the Internet unless you've fully researched the plan independently and you've made the call to the company. Also, be sure any membership fees are refundable if you choose to cancel and what the process for canceling will be.
Before signing up for any discount plan, call your state insurance department and the Better Business Bureau to see if other consumers have complained about the discount card you are considering. If you do suspect a scam, report what you found to your state insurance department, as well as the Better Business Bureau.
Lita Epstein has written more than 25 books including "Surviving a Layoff: A Week-by-Week Guide to Getting Your Life Back Together" and "Working After Retirement for Dummies."
- YUM: Where to Find the Best Airport Food - Forbes
- LIST: America's Most Efficiently Run Brands - 24/7 Wall St.
- BEWARE: New Credit-Card Tricks Snare Consumers - MarketWatch
- HOTTEST GADGETRY: 20 Back-to-School Devices - TIME.com
- TOXIC: Three Mutual Fund Warning Signs - InvestorPlace
- FLAME-OUT: What Went Wrong at Burger King - FORTUNE
- PONY UP: Most Expensive College Football Tickets - CNBC

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
2-15-2010 @ 9:19AM
The Health Dude said...
While health is wealth most of our people no good health and it is the reality that they have no wealth to keep health well. To keep good health we also need wealth. Health is wealth? Not always that!
Reply
2-15-2010 @ 10:31AM
Mike said...
Since this is not insurance, there would an issue should someone then want to enroll in insurance. Lack of previous coverage may trigger more exclusions or an assessment of insureability. I have seen these types of clauses when I have switched coverage.
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 9:18AM
Joe The Health Geek said...
A scam is a scam. Unfortunately, the options we have for health insurance are expensive due to the cost of catastrophic care. Nobody will go broke paying for office visits out of pocket however an overnight hospital stay could break a fragile bank account. If you're looking to cut costs on Health premiums, its better to increase copays and deductibles rather than jump to a program thats too good to be true.
In addition, it is always better to check-in with a legitamate broker to make sure that the poilcy your considering is legit!
Joe www.HealthInsuranceGeeks.com
Reply
2-23-2010 @ 6:36AM
Steve said...
Stay away for AMACORE Stock symbol ACGI the article must have been written about them. REAL SCAM....Try to pretend they are major medical but just a discount at best and the insurance portion of the program wouldn't provide enough $$ get you dog covered at thev Vet. It's a shame that these people are able to take advantage of us. I wonder what plans the executives of Amacore have on their families? I would bet not their plan!
Reply
2-26-2010 @ 4:44PM
Andrea Bevington said...
As the author pointed out, not all discount programs are scams. OptumHealth Allies (www.optumhealthallies.com) offers our members real savings on out-of-pocket health care purchases. We believe consumers should not have to pay full price for health care. While we can't always provide our members with the deeply discounted rates that insurance companies get, we can generally save them 10 to 35 percent on medical and dental care, and often much as 50 percent on other health services.
We take great pains to make sure our members have a postive experience. Our "minimum discount guarantee" policy that states that if the member does not receive the advertised discount, we will refund the difference... and we do, every day.
Discount plans are no substitute for comprehensive insurance. But, they can be a valuable savings tool for consumers. State regulations have driven many unscrupulous operators from the market, but there are still some out there. To learn more about the discount health industry and how to distinguish legitimate operators from scam artists, visit the Consumer Health Alliance at www. consumerhealthalliance.com.
Reply
2-26-2010 @ 5:40PM
Best Discount Benefits said...
Discount medical programs differ from healthcare insurance in several important ways. Discount health care plans are available to anyone. Unlike traditional insurance, you are immediately qualified. There can be no denial for health conditions, you may begin using services immediately, and there is no paper work to process. Services are unlimited throughout your membership period for the same low membership fee. Getting started is easy, and your acceptance is guaranteed.
Your membership fee entitles you to unlimited services throughout the year with no maximums on services. You may receive services as often as needed and still receive the same pre-negotiated discounted rates. In comparison, traditional insurance requires costly deductibles, imposes limits on the number of times you can receive services and establishes annual maximums on services.
Simply enroll online anytime, and you are immediately accepted regardless of your age or pre-existing conditions. A membership card will arrive by mail in 7-10 business days. Once you have located a provider in your area using the Provider Services Directory, simply make an appointment and show your membership card when you arrive for your appointment. Then you just pay the pre-negotiated discounted rate at your time of service. You'll love how you save money using these plans. Don't get caught paying full price for your health care!
http://BestDiscountBenefits.com/
Reply
3-14-2010 @ 7:50PM
alison said...
Very true Sam. Most of my coworkers make their decision on which plan to pick by the monthly cost and have no idea what coverage they have, their deductible, copay, disability coverage, etc.
Reply
3-28-2010 @ 7:50AM
AdoraStaten said...
Do your research, check for providers and make an informed decision. Ameriplan is not insurance but offers discounts on numerous health/medical procedures. Worth looking into if you can't get health insurance for whatever reason or don't qualify for state aid. One thing I like about this company is they stay true to what they offer and they have month to month plans so your locked up for life and can use it when you need to. Check out: www.MyBenefitsPlus.com/tj
Reply