Skip to Content

Listen to the Joystiq Podcast (because your ears can't read)

Could banks be in more trouble than they've let on?

More
Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Banks, Real Estate

Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke recently talked about "green shoots" of economic recovery and declared the recession probably over, but some economists fear the worst is yet to come.

As bad as the residential real estate crisis was for banks, the impact of failed residential mortgages could be dwarfed by the problems now facing the banks regarding commercial real estate.

A loan for a commercial building like a shopping mall is very different from the mortgage you have on your home. Commercial mortgages have a much shorter term, usually only five to seven years. The bank doesn't expect the owner to pay the debt off in that amount of time, but when that time comes, they need to refinance the remaining balance into a new loan.


Do a little math, and the problem becomes clear: Many loans that were made during the peak of the boom are going to be coming due within the next year or two. Owners can't refinance because their vacancy rates have skyrocketed even as banks have tightened their lending requirements. Malls, office complexes and warehouses all have high -- in some cases, record high -- vacancy rates because so many businesses have folded.

This already bad news is magnified by the fact that no one really knows how big this problem could get until we're in the middle of it.

According to this Fortune article, some experts are warning that banks might be underestimating the amount of losses they could incur and aren't socking away enough of a fiscal cushion to help them weather commercial defaults.

Why wouldn't banks want to protect themselves? Part of the problem is that no one has a good grasp on just how much the properties that back the loan are worth. Banks all have to do their own calculations to try and figure out how much these loans are worth since there's no standard formula for factoring in the impact of the recession.

Think about it: If four houses on a street sell at foreclosure, when the fifth one forecloses, people have a good idea how much it will fetch at auction because they have other examples with which to compare it. But if the biggest shopping mall in the county is in foreclosure, how do you even begin to figure out how much that's actually worth, especially given that this economy means there's a dearth of deep-pocketed buyers out there?

According to one study cited in the Fortune article, commercial real estate prices have dropped by roughly one-third over the past year.

A research company quoted in the article says banks collectively should brace for $110 billion in losses but adds that banks have only counted about a third of those losses so far.

There are a few complicated accounting tricks banks can employ to make their bad debts look a little less bad, but these kinds of maneuvers are only effective for a limited time. Some experts worry that shareholders aren't getting the full picture of how much trouble banks are in when it comes to commercial real estate losses.

One thing is clear, though: We're not out of the woods yet.
Subscribe to Walletpop

Add your comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments.

When you enter your name and email address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. To leave another comment, just use that password.

To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or email address and we will make it a live link for you. You can put up to 3 URLs in your comments. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br /> tags.

How Much Should I Save?

$
$
%
The Most Impressive Desserts
Looking to impress your guests with a dessert to die for? Or maybe you'd like to bring something ...
How to Choose the Most Flattering Hat
Adding a hat can make or break an ensemble, not to mention either flatter your face and highlight ...

Tom Barlow
Tom Barlow Filed under: Health, Wealth

Want happiness? Forget money - get therapy instead

If money doesn't bring happiness, why do we devote so much of our energy chasing it? Perhaps the old adage is flawed, but not according to a study recently completed at the Universities of Warwick and ...
Lita Epstein
Lita Epstein Filed under: Health

Nightmare public hospital to be reborn as private hospital

You may remember the video reports of Edith Rodriguez, a 43-year-old woman seen dying in the emergency room of a hospital in Los Angeles. Well, that hospital was the Martin Luther King Jr.-Harbor ...
Charles Feldman
Charles Feldman Filed under: Real Estate, Recession, Investing, Mortgages

Why Dubai should matter to you; U.S. real estate could take big hit!

Funny thing this globalization: Just when you think everything is starting to settle down and maybe, just maybe, the world's economic plight is finally on the mend, along comes news from a place such ...
Geoff Williams
Geoff Williams Filed under: Debt, Credit cards

Showing this weekend at a movie theater near you: credit card advice

In the midst of all your shopping on Black Friday and in the aftermath, are you planning on taking in a movie? Before you watch the latest Twilight movie, or Ninja Assassin or whatever you think will ...

Banking Tools

Use these bank account calculators and tools to help you make the smartest bank account moves.

    Headlines from WalletPop Partners