Why did the chicken cross the road? To get on a ship in China
Filed under: Food, Consumer Ally
So, the U.S. Senate and House have agreed that it is now time to give consumers another Chinese product to help lower production costs, create more jobs overseas and increase corporate profits: chicken. Chinese chicken imports had been banned for the past couple of years after Congress put the kibosh on a trade plan from the Bush administration in 2007. A U.S. Department of Agriculture inspection of Chinese poultry plants in 2004 documented poor sanitary conditions.
But the Obama administration appears to have succeeded where Bush failed, convincing Congress that Chinese chickens are good for relations with our manufacturing friends in the Far East.
Politics is great for delivering examples of how failure can be a good thing.
Shouldn't the line be drawn somewhere? Processed chicken seems like a good place to start.
Let's be clear: Chinese products are with us everywhere and the lower prices that come with them have become addictive to consumers.
Electronic equipment, toys, and even candy comes here by the freighter load and consumers buy it by the truckload. Some of it -- not that China has cornered the market on it -- is utter junk. And products made in China tend not only dominate what we find in discount stores, but also the list of products that are recalled due to defects or violations of safety rules.
American companies, such as chicken-producing giant Tyson Foods, played a role in pushing for the agreement that will open the doors to Chinese chicken products in the U.S. It owns chicken farms in China, and stands to profit mightily from the lower cost of doing business in China. Who can blame them?
The Chinese track record with food safety is abysmal. Less than a year ago, Chinese health officials (pictured above) killed and disposed of tens of thousands of chickens exposed to the avian flu. That was about the same time nearly 300,000 Chinese babies took ill after drinking melamine-tainted powdered milk. And, as it turns out, melamine also was found in chicken feed and, of course, in Chinese chicken products.
But Congress agreed to open the markets here to Chinese chicken provided an inspection process was instituted that supposedly would ensure Chinese chicken production would meet U.S. standards. That provision crumbled the opposition. U.S. Rep. Rosa Delauro, D-Conn., previously an opponent, explained in an article she penned for Roll Call that enough safeguards have been put in place for her to support the new plan.
Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown, who has urged toughness regarding Chinese imports without a lot of success, said the whole issue comes down to a game of chicken.
""The Chinese don't play fair, and we've been cowards," the senator told Fortune. "Every time China threatens, we back off."
The U.S. market for apple juice (what's more American than that?) is dominated by products whose roots are a powdery concentrate shipped on freighters in 55-gallon drums from where else but China. Most U.S. consumers don't care, or at least don't pay much attention, to China being the nation of origin of most of the "juice" in drink boxes and apple juice bottles sold in this country. And since no big problems have been reported with Chinese apple products they have become ubiquitous here. Only a handful of companies claim to only use U.S.-grown apples.
Not long ago I bought a piece of frozen salmon in a package. Even though I obsessively check certain products for nation of origin labeling, I didn't notice this one until it was too late: China. My salmon was from China. I have lived in Alaska and fished salmon from Nushagak Bay on the Bering Sea coast. To the fine people there, I apologize.
Perhaps it is a simplistic notion or overly protectionist, but with the backdrop of millions of recalled products, melamine-tainted food and bird flu on the resume of the nation of origin, is it too much to ask of the U.S. government to refrain from giving passports to millions of pounds of processed Chinese chicken products?




Reader Comments (Page 1 of 9)
10-08-2009 @ 6:54PM
Guy said...
Working and living in China the last 5 years you see alot that you don't see from the other side of the pond. Are prices really cheaper for the Consumer? Maybe the big man (CEO) has found a way to make a larger profit?????
Reply
10-09-2009 @ 8:18AM
fz said...
America is probably the safest (most regulated) place to raise any type of food for the masses. The safety and job(income) security of our citizens should be weighed against political expediency and corporate profits gained from imports. We the People need to make money in order to spend it. Two generations ago we loaned money to the world to buy our stuff, now the world loans us money to buy their stuff, or for the govt. to use it to temporarily stimulate an economy that has no true foundation.
Reply
10-11-2009 @ 5:45AM
fubar said...
No, its really not the most regulated place to raise food for the masses... you might want to look at the UK, in the wake of scandals around Mad cow disease, foot and mouth and poultry based salmonella, the restrictions of food produce there are easily more stringent than here in the US...
10-13-2009 @ 12:26AM
Steve Corby said...
You say that our country has the most regulated food industry...Have you ever worked in a slaughter house?and see what goes on...I think not ...Go to a local butcher and buy a T-Bone steak then go to a grocery store and buy the same thing ...Which one would you eat?
10-13-2009 @ 8:55AM
Mickey M said...
You are kidding, right? Safest, most regulated place - not hardly. The Bush Administration reduced OSHA and the FDA to little more than offices of a few overworked people unable to do the jobs they were hired to do - keep us safe. Remember the e coli lettuce fiasco that took so long to control, and the number of people who managed to become ill or die from that? Or the incredible number of beef recalls we had during the eight years they were in office, and peanuts?
10-09-2009 @ 8:49AM
Mia said...
NO.....I may have limited my diet, but I do know where my food is coming from. I will not buy anything from China. Your bargain from China may cost in the long run in medical bills.
Reply
10-13-2009 @ 4:12PM
Lis said...
I feel the same way, I don't trust any of the manufacturers outside the US; and even ours I question sometimes. Please give me some good choices!
10-09-2009 @ 11:10AM
Suzanne Ormsby said...
I won't even give my dogs chicken jerkey snacks anymore since I found out where this meat comes from. I buy the American made brand now for them. Might pay a little more but feel better about it. The Chinese do not play fair at all and see us as Stupid Americans.
Reply
10-10-2009 @ 11:51AM
janine said...
you are so right. they have try to kill off our dogs and cats and now the stupid government is trusting them with buying more junk. we need to buy american so our people have jobs wake !!!
10-09-2009 @ 11:14AM
crazydmp said...
we get enough CRAP that is tainted from China
this is why you shouldn't have borrowed all that
money for your stimilus.
Guess Purdue, Tyson and other manufacturers
will have to close up and move out.
Reply
10-09-2009 @ 4:56PM
joe said...
Tyson Foods is behind this. They aren't going to close. Some poor American Chicken Farmer will.
10-09-2009 @ 11:46AM
Brennie said...
Having consumed beef from new mexico and getting deathly ill, (They snuck that one on me), there is no way I would ever willingly eat chicken from China! I keep my eyes on labels much more closely these days. There is so much more that I would like to say but the net is running slow today Buyer beware!
Reply
10-09-2009 @ 3:50PM
Cher said...
Brennie, I don't understand the connection you are trying to make, what does "Having consumed beef from new mexico and getting deathly ill" have to do with chickens from China?
And for the record, I will not eat or use anything made, grown or produced in China.
10-12-2009 @ 10:24PM
DLRiggs said...
Brennie,
I'm sorry to be the one to tell you this. . but New Mexico is part of the US! Don't quote me, but I think it was the 47th state! US beef is served there. Sometimes though packaged hamburger is used by restaurants that is not always US Beef. So, I always steer clear of pre-packaged hamburger that's not clearly marked.
10-13-2009 @ 1:06AM
Lyn said...
New Mexico became a state in 1912. It is located between Texas and Arizona. In the part of New Mexico that I used to live in, they raised beef. However, most of the beef we ate came from large processors in the east . . .
I try not to buy anything from China. It's getting harder to do so, but at least until now most food in the stores I shop in came from the US, Mexico or South America.
How can it be cheaper to grow chickens in China and ship them here? What a waste of oil, and for something we can raise here!
10-09-2009 @ 11:57AM
mike said...
Have Obama'skids eat it for a year if they live I'll feed it to my neighbors dogs.
Reply
10-09-2009 @ 8:14PM
mary said...
fool!
10-09-2009 @ 8:17PM
candy said...
A**
10-13-2009 @ 6:51AM
Lavonn said...
I don't care who you are, that is funny Mike.
I am only commenting on the humor of this particular post not anything else.
10-09-2009 @ 11:59AM
regina said...
we need to demand to see USA labels on our food products....and we need to stare looking for that....i did at Meijers
and i made sure that if i seen anyone picking up meat products
that they seen the label. they did not like what they seen and Meijers heard from them.....You will see USA- CANDA-MEXICO
Don't fall for this crap....we have to take a stand.....we have been to passive to long....i wont eat at fast food places because they are bringing in meat from other countries...
our moto should be
NO MORE NO DAM WAY!!!!!!!!!!!
PS...Meijer has a very good selection of USA meat...at least in michigan.
Reply