Skip to Content

A bill for a bill? What gives?

More
Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Ripoffs and Scams, Saving Money, Technology, Consumer Complaints

Consumers who haven't migrated their bill receiving functions online are increasingly finding that they're at the mercy of companies now charging for paper statements. It's a source of irritation for many who feel that businesses have no right to charge for information that informs consumers how much is owed.

For many, including Rob Connor of Charleston, S.C., providing an itemized, paper bill is simply a cost of doing business companies must incur, and one that shouldn't be foisted upon consumers' wallets.

Connor's beef is with mobile-phone company T-Mobile, a unit of Deutsche Telecom AG, which recently sent him a note advising that it will soon begin charging $1.50 a month to receive a summary paper bill and $3.50 a month for detailed statement.
It's an imposition for Connor, who doesn't have Internet access at his home. T-Mobile is making the change, which takes effect this month, in part to help the environment, it says, but Connor isn't swayed.

"This thing of having to pay so I can pay is just a little too much," he told MSNBC's Red Tape Chronicles. "And I'm certainly not interested in some bogus argument about me contributing to global warming by NOT signing on to making it cheaper for T-Mobile to send me a bill."

T-Mobile isn't alone in promoting paperless billing. Sprint, for example, offers a $5 credit to customers who opt for electronic bills and cable-television provider Time Warner offers its customers a $1 monthly credit to forgo paper statements.

But T-Mobile's decision to charge even for a summary bill puts the company in a unique, scrooge-ish league.

After considering several factors, including costs and environmental impact, T-Mobile has begun charging for paper bills, the company told MSNBC. It noted that detailed billing information is freely available online and in some instances through consumers' cell phones.

The practice of charging for paper bills raises a larger question in the minds of consumer advocates: Do companies have the right to charge for information to which consumers have every right? It certainly has ignited a debate on the company's Forums page at its Web site. One contributor said in part: "I'm not happy about this. As a consumer I'm appalled and regardless of one's opinion on the matter as a consumer we should all be appalled."

Others questioned whether T-Mobile's decision doesn't constitute a change in the company's terms of service, which would allow users angry about the charge to walk away from the carrier without penalty.


Harvey Rosenfeld, founder of Consumer Watchdog, told MSNBC that consumers have every right to be angry. They are entitled to receive bills and invoices that detail costs.

"You need to know if you're being overcharged, if you've received a promotional discount," he said. "You can't figure anything out from a bill if all they give you is a single unitemized bill."

Further, if a company begins charging for a service it previously provided for nothing, "that's a material change for sure," he said. "I think consumers can get out of their contracts."
http://xml.channel.aol.com/xmlpublisher/fetch.v2.xml?option=expand_relative_urls&dataUrlNodes=uiConfig,feedConfig,entry&id=473989&pid=473988&uts=1251914271
http://cdn.channel.aol.com/cs_feed_v1_6/csfeedwrapper.swf
10 Things Your Supermarket Won't Tell You
For a look at supermarket secrets, click through our gallery.
Getty Images
AP
WalletPop is not responsible for caption content.
Subscribe to Walletpop

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)

Your Frugal Tips

dollar bill in sandwichBeing frugal is now hip, but many don't even know where to start. Share your best money-saving secrets here!

    AOL Safeguards

    Julia Scott
    Julia Scott Filed under: Bargain Babe

    Book it! Borders 30% off through Dec. 24

    Get 30% off one regular priced item at Borders Dec. 22-24, 2009. Some exclusions. Print the coupon here. You must belong to its free loyalty program, called Borders Rewards. Use code BSL7023C. Online ...
    Laura Heller
    Laura Heller Filed under: Extracurriculars

    Wal-Mart jobs: Ever wonder what it's like to work there?

    Getting a peek inside a major retailer can yield some pretty revealing information about their business and culture. It's not an easy thing to arrange -- there are hoops to jump through, media ...
    Lou Carlozo
    Lou Carlozo Filed under: Recession Diaries

    10 reasons for pocketbook optimism after a financially shaky 2009

    I lost my job of 16 years in 2009, and perhaps your luck was no better. I certainly wouldn't blame you if you looked at 2009 as one to forget where your wallet is concerned. But as the "aughts" turn ...
    Tom Barlow
    Tom Barlow Filed under: Health

    Virtual doctor visits -- the future of American medicine arrives

    What if you could visit a doctor, any time of day or night, without leaving your home, and that doctor could review your history, diagnose your problem and phone in a prescription? That's the pitch ...

    Headlines from WalletPop Partners

    Readers' Choice Awards for Best in Winter Travel
    Do you know of a cruise line that offers everything from beautiful accommodations to great dining, ...
    How to Store Cheese
    How long can you keep cheese in your refrigerator? Why should you keep your cheese in the vegetable ...
    Learn More»