Skip to Content

'Fighting Chance' effective tool in negotiating new-car deals

Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Bargains, Shopping, Transportation

General Motors' decision to partner with eBay in a test program in California to sell cars via the Internet may seem like a simple way to buy a car without entering a showroom.

But if you're not in the Golden State and still in the market for a new ride there are other ways to get a great deal without ever leaving the comfort of home or the office.

There are numerous Web sites that provide information about car buying and prices. Some, such as Edmunds, have been around for decades. Kelly Blue Book, AOL Autos and MSN Autos have similar information. As with Edmunds, you can choose a make and model, build it to your specifications, and learn both invoice -- what the dealer paid -- and sticker prices.

Though these free sites provide useful information and can act as primer when diving into the fretful world of new-car buying, their ability to negotiate price is negligible. After submitting a form with contact information requesting a quote from several dealers in your area, all you do is cross your fingers and hope for the best.

James Bragg says that that's far from the best way to make a deal. Bragg founded Fighting Chance some 15 years ago with the idea of arming consumers with up-to-minute information on prices and incentives to help them negotiate the best new-car deal.

For a fee -- $39.95 for one model; $15 for each additional vehicle -- Fighting Chance e-mails a package that includes pricing, rebate and market information about the specific vehicles you requested and how to go about negotiating the best deal.

Bragg believes many customers overpay because they wrongly bargain down from the sticker price or believe that they will pay no lower than invoice price.

But that's not necessarily the case. Given the complexity of manufacturers relationships with dealers and the incentives provided to them, it is difficult to know exactly how much profit your local dealer is making from the car you want. In other words, even if the dealer agrees to sell at invoice price he may still make money on the deal, through additional profits known as "holdbacks" and other incentives.

The Fighting Chance system isn't as simple as surfing eBay. It involves either faxing or e-mailing specific contacts -- generally, sales managers -- within each dealership with which you're willing to work, being specific about the car you want, including colors, and asking for the agent's best price.

But, it can be a surprisingly fast and effective tool in negotiating a deal on a new car, as I found out a few years ago when helping my mother, who lives several hundred miles away, buy a new Buick. Within minutes of e-mailing several dealers in her area, I'd received either phone calls ( I provided a cell phone number by which to be reached ) or by e-mail, offering their best price on a car they had in stock.

By the next day, she had a new car matching her specifications and at a price she wouldn't have likely gotten had she simply filled out a generic form on the internet or walked into the showroom on her own. And I got peace of mind knowing my mother hadn't paid out the nose for her new car.
If you're interested in transportation, you may like
these related sites for: Maps, Driving Directions, Travel, and Cars.
Subscribe to Walletpop

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)

Find Your Next Car

Find Your Next Car

AOL Autos New Cars and Used Cars
Readers' Choice Winners for Best in Winter Travel
Votes have been cast for Best Ski Hotel, Best International Ski Destination, Best Caribbean Cruise ...
Readers' Choice Awards for Best in Sweets
Is there a maker of fine chocolate candy that makes your mouth water just thinking about it? Who ...

Ask the Dolans

Have a question about the "Cash for Clunkers" program or any other personal finance subject? Ken & Daria Dolan are here to help.

Ask your own questions to the Dolans

Julia Scott
Julia Scott Filed under: Bargain Babe

Borders coupon for 33% off

Here is the latest coupon from Borders. Get 33% off any one regular-priced item today through Thursday, Feb. 11. Some exclusions. Online use coupon code BSL7210X. One per person. The coupon also ...
Tom Barlow
Tom Barlow Filed under: Food

No seed shortage for gardeners this spring, despite reports to the contrary

Thanks to the recession, more Americans are interested in growing their own vegetables. Bad timing, according to an Associated Press report that seeds for some popular veggies might be in short supply ...
Mitch Lipka
Mitch Lipka Filed under: Recalls, Consumer Ally

Deaths spark crib recall: CSPC says to stop using Generation 2 and ChildESIGNS cribs

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission is issuing a crib recall and warning anyone with Generation 2 Worldwide or "ChildESIGNS" drop side cribs to stop using them following reports of the deaths ...
Zac Bissonnette
Zac Bissonnette Filed under: Real Estate

Survey says? Homeowners think real estate collapse is over

A Thomson Reuters/University of Michigan survey published last week suggests that most homeowners think the worst is over, and don't anticipate further declines in the value of their properties in ...

Most Popular Car Makers



Headlines from WalletPop Partners