Skip to Content

Don't worry. You're not going to have to fly standing up

Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Transportation, Travel, Consumer Complaints

As newspapers die and take substantive news with them, the Internet is turning into a carnival of odd tidbits. The weirder or more alarming the story, the faster word flits from screen to screen.

This week, a prime nugget from the News of the Weird had to do with Spring Airlines, a fledgling Chinese carrier that is petitioning its government to allow passengers to fly standing up.

Having passengers stand up, the way they do on a subway or a bus, would stuff 50% more people into planes, reducing costs.

Ryanair, an Irish company that never saw a cheap publicity trick it didn't love, tried to act like it was inspired to consider a similar move. It might give a section of passengers barstools instead of proper chairs, envisioned its boss, Michael O'Leary, or it could even let people fly for free if they stood up -- paying the carrier's extravagant fees to take any luggage, of course.



It's funny to imagine that United or Delta might make us start doing it, too, and that makes for an inflammatory e-mail forward, but Americans can relax.

You're not going to have to fly standing up anytime soon, and here is the simple reason: The Federal Aviation Administration requires that you sit on flights. It's in its Airworthiness Standards code, Title 14, 23.785. Don't take my word for it. Just read the code yourself: "There must be a seat or berth for each occupant."

Since the airlines aren't about to lose precious floor space by granting us the dignity of berths (beds), that leaves seats, and since the FAA isn't about to alter its safety rules so the airlines can wring another few bucks out of us, that rules out standing.


Another stipulation that would seem to eliminate standing says that each passenger is assigned a restraint system that "must be designed to support occupants weighing at least 215 pounds." Your own two feet, then, don't count. Berths must also be "installed parallel to the longitudinal axis of the airplane." That means they can't be straight up and down, as a passenger-size stall would have to be.

Although Airbus has been trying for years to inaugurate legal standing-room flights in Asia -- apparently the only place where the jet manufacturer thinks the value of human comfort is low enough and the population density high enough -- but so far, no government has gone for it.

Spring Airlines' managers think that the idea may have wings in China at least, because it was that country's vice premier who suggested the idea to begin with. Even if it becomes a reality there, SRO flights won't be permitted to touch down outside of China unless its destination country endorsed that configuration, too.

No, for now the airlines are content to convey teeming swarms of passengers the old-fashioned way. They'll just reduce legroom to kneecap-knocking intimacy and make the seats thinner than the crackers they no longer serve.
If you're interested in transportation, you may like
these related sites for: Maps, Driving Directions, Travel, and Cars.
Subscribe to Walletpop

Find Your Next Car

Find Your Next Car

AOL Autos New Cars and Used Cars
Readers' Choice Winners for Best in Winter Travel
Votes have been cast for Best Ski Hotel, Best International Ski Destination, Best Caribbean Cruise ...
Readers' Choice Awards for Best in Sweets
Is there a maker of fine chocolate candy that makes your mouth water just thinking about it? Who ...

Ask the Dolans

Have a question about the "Cash for Clunkers" program or any other personal finance subject? Ken & Daria Dolan are here to help.

Ask your own questions to the Dolans

Julia Scott
Julia Scott Filed under: Bargain Babe

Borders coupon for 33% off

Here is the latest coupon from Borders. Get 33% off any one regular-priced item today through Thursday, Feb. 11. Some exclusions. Online use coupon code BSL7210X. One per person. The coupon also ...
Tom Barlow
Tom Barlow Filed under: Food

No seed shortage for gardeners this spring, despite reports to the contrary

Thanks to the recession, more Americans are interested in growing their own vegetables. Bad timing, according to an Associated Press report that seeds for some popular veggies might be in short supply ...
Mitch Lipka
Mitch Lipka Filed under: Recalls, Consumer Ally

Deaths spark crib recall: CSPC says to stop using Generation 2 and ChildESIGNS cribs

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission is issuing a crib recall and warning anyone with Generation 2 Worldwide or "ChildESIGNS" drop side cribs to stop using them following reports of the deaths ...
Zac Bissonnette
Zac Bissonnette Filed under: Real Estate

Survey says? Homeowners think real estate collapse is over

A Thomson Reuters/University of Michigan survey published last week suggests that most homeowners think the worst is over, and don't anticipate further declines in the value of their properties in ...

Most Popular Car Makers



Headlines from WalletPop Partners