Skip to Content

High court says, skip those commercials!

More
Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Technology, Consumer Complaints

Many of us -- this blogger included -- like the idea of whizzing past commercials to get back to our favorite programs sooner, but put up with having our viewing interrupted by Madison Avenue because we're resistant to the idea of shelling out a couple hundred bucks for a digital video recorder.

Soon, though, those days of being forced to sit through talking animals and how-did-that-get-stuck-in-my-head jingles might be over, thanks to the Supreme Court. Yes, that Supreme Court.

While the nation's highest justices don't normally insert themselves into our TV habits (thankfully -- I'd hate to be judged for my addictions to Hell's Kitchen or Law & Order: SVU), in this case, it's a welcome involvement.

Let's cue up a Fred Savage-era voiceover and go back to when this all began. In 2006, New York cable operator Cablevision developed what it called "network" DVR. This would let viewers store programs for later viewing on the cable company's servers rather than in a DVR box on their set top. Think of it as the equivalent of using a Web-based e-mail program; all of your information is housed in some distant server, not in your computer itself.

The implications are obvious: With this technology, any TV could record and play back shows, provided you were paying Cablevision for digital cable service. No pricey box, no installation fees or headaches. Now, take one guess who was not a fan of this new development. That's right: the people who currently make money forcing you to watch those commercials.A consortium of TV programmers representing a handful of networks sued, claiming Cablevision's new technology amounted to illegal copying of copyrighted material. They claimed that shows stored in an individual's DVR were in some significant way different from those same shows if they were stored on Cablevision's servers.

Of course, the networks also had a strong incentive to keep more Americans from having access to DVR technology. The prospect of widespread DVR usage spells trouble for networks, since -- no big surprise here -- when given the option, we tend to skip over commercials.

With TV networks already fighting to combat viewer defections to the Web and DVD services like Netflix, any large-scale defection could put a serious dent in the amount they can charge advertisers.

A federal court initially sided with the networks, but Cablevision won out in an appeal. The networks took the case to the Supreme Court, which announced yesterday it was refusing to review the networks' appeal, granting Cablevision a legal victory. The cable operator said it would start rolling out some features of the new technology to customers this summer.

No doubt, the networks will wring their hands and try to invent even more crafty ways to get ads in front of our eyeballs, but this is still a victory for viewers. Just think; by this time next year, the "Five-Dollar Footlong" song or the Cockney-accented gecko could be little more than distant memories.
Subscribe to Walletpop

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)

Vote Now For the Readers' Choice Best in Food Awards
Nominations have been received and vetted for the best-of-breed in gourmet grocers, online gourmet ...
Zingerman's Bakehouse: Artisan Bread and Pastry from Ann Arbor
Zingerman's Bakehouse of Ann Arbor, Michigan, is nominated for a Luxist Award in the best bread ...

Jason Cochran
Jason Cochran Filed under: Bargains, Extracurriculars, Transportation, Travel, Celebs & Money

On board the new Oasis of the Seas: Is it worth the money?

So here I am, writing this from off the coast of Florida as part of the first two-day preview cruise of the magnificent Oasis of the Seas. Royal Caribbean has launched the largest cruise ship in the ...
Geoff Williams
Geoff Williams Filed under: Credit cards

Citigroup holds its customers hostage

Across the nation, Citibank credit card holders are receiving what pretty much amounts to a ransom note: We're going to raise your rates, says the letter, in so many words, but if you spend more ...
Bonnie McCarthy
Bonnie McCarthy Filed under: Budgets, Kids and Money, Saving Money, Technology

Family budgets: Make movie night safe again with family-friendly review sites

Around my house, we don't make the decision to pile into the car and head over to our local Cineplex as easily as we once did. It costs a lot of money these days to see talking animals, wild things ...
Madhusmita Bora
Madhusmita Bora Filed under: Transportation

Shop the friendly skies? The airlines are hoping you'll buy while in the sky

Along with sandwiches and soda, you may one day be able to buy tickets to Lion King and Animal Kingdom while cruising 35,000 feet above ground. A New York Times story reported that the airline ...

Headlines from WalletPop Partners