Skip to Content

Illegal file-sharing costly at $80,000 per song

More
Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Technology

The Universal Music Group and other music labels won a $1.92 million judgment against a Minnesota woman who illegally shared 80 songs with other users over Kazaa, the popular online file-sharing service.

That's right: The federal jury decided that the piracy was worth $80,000 per song. The defendant's response? "The only thing I can say is good luck trying to get it, because you can't get blood out of a turnip." Her lawyer has said that they are planning to either appeal or settle the judgment for a more reasonable sum.

What makes the case so unusual is that it actually went to trial. The Recording Industry Association of America has brought more than 35,000 legal actions against people it believes have infringed on its copyrights, but those cases are almost always settled quickly.

This lady tried to argue that it wasn't her who had downloaded the songs and apparently the jury wasn't buying it. Perhaps they were extra tough in the penalty phase because they thought she was a liar.

The lesson for everyone at home here is clear: Do not ever, ever, ever download files illegally with a service like Kazaa, and make sure that your kids don't either.

True: You probably won't get caught, but it's just not worth the risk. Spend the $1 and download the songs on iTunes, or just find them on YouTube if you're determined not to give $1 to the industry.
Subscribe to Walletpop

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)

Vote Now For The Readers' Choice for Best in Accessories
Nominations have been received and vetted for the best-of-breed in jewelry, watches, leathergoods, ...
Gucci: Nobility Inspired Italian Craftsmanship
Gucci has been nominated for the Luxist Awards in the category of Best Leathergoods Line, in ...

Geoff Williams
Geoff Williams Filed under: Banks

More bank failures expected; how you check the health of yours

The banks may be paying back their bailout funds, but there's still trouble ahead for some banks. That became clear this week when the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation agreed to almost double the ...
Aaron Crowe
Aaron Crowe Filed under: Career, Recession

Act like a guerrilla in your job search

Tired of getting nowhere in sales at a cemetery and essentially unemployed, Gail Neal decided to expand her job search. Neal, who lives in Detroit, Mich., where 15.1% unemployment makes it one of ...
Lan N. Nguyen
Lan N. Nguyen Filed under: College, Saving Money, Bankruptcy

WalletPop experts answer your bankruptcy and college savings questions

The Dow may be over 10,000, but unease about the economy persists as unemployment hovers over 10%. To help ease some of your concerns, WalletPop is ready to answer your personal finance questions. ...
Martha C. White
Martha C. White Filed under: Credit cards

Americans ditching predatory credit cards

We here at WalletPop read a lot of comments about how angry Americans are with their credit card companies. We read a lot of missives from people who claim that the combination of rate hikes, fee ...

Headlines from WalletPop Partners