Simon Cowell misses the big Susan Boyle payday
Filed under: Extracurriculars, Technology, Wealth, Celebs & Money
It's been estimated that nearly 100 million people have now seen Britain's Got Talent contestant Susan Boyle perform "I Dreamed a Dream." She's an overnight tabloid sensation, a champion of the showtune, and a balm for the unappreciated of the world. She may even be a poster girl for mental disabilities. This closet crooner is well on her way to performing for the Queen -- and by that, I mean Oprah.But no one's making any money off her yet. Even though her YouTube video has been seen by so many people, somewhere along the way, Simon Cowell and his media partners failed to get money out of it. And it didn't have to be that way.
Cowell's label, ITV (the show's British TV network) and YouTube have a revenue-sharing agreement, which some say should be netting them a half cent per play. That would mean a check for $500,000 just based on the last two weeks of viral video watching alone. And if Google ads had been sold for that video, too, the payday could leap by the millions.
But Wired reports that it hasn't been done. FremantleMedia, which produces the show, declined to comment, and Google said "that video is not being monetized," meaning no one's getting a piece of the action. So far, the Susan Boyle tidal wave has failed to drench anyone in a wave of cash. A Wired blogger theorizes that music licensing is to blame. Les Misérables, the source of the song, is still playing in London and Amsterdam, after all.
The media companies are being truly stupid about this one, and it affects us, too. A smart TV exec would have quickly inked a deal to start showing Britain's Got Talent to Yanks the moment Susan Boyle became a web phenom. She was on the first episode of the season, so we wouldn't have missed a thing. BBC America, a logical home channel for the show, already airs plenty of ITV programs. But, as Entertainment Weekly sullenly points out, no one has made that deal, either, and we can't stream full episodes online, either.
Americans can't see the entire show if we wanted to. Then again, Britain has stupidly blocked much of its culture from being exported to us online despite the fact we are not permitted to buy it though other means. Countless British smashes, from their terrific version of The Apprentice (with Sir Alan Sugar as a gruff, unshaven version of Trump) to its seminal version of Big Brother to the international springtime sensation the Eurovision Song Contest, are not available to us. Try to watch online, and you'll find them blocked to American IP addresses. Who can say how many cash cows are being denied the bigger American market?
The censorship, blamed on rights, goes both ways. The Brits are blocked from watching shows like The View online, as we can. Don't know why. It's not like there'll be a boxed set they can buy later. (Thank goodness, perhaps.)
As for Boyle herself, she's still just a contestant, so she won't get a piece of anything until the winner is announced. At this rate, though, as the media companies bungle the cash-in, by the end of all this, she may be the only one laughing. I think it's safe to say that even if she doesn't win, she'll easily score a record deal on the back of her insta-fame. Watch that YouTube video again, and if you look closely, you can see little pound signs dancing in Simon's eyes. She's already received offers for film roles, both of the B-grade and blue varieties (yes, an L.A. porno company wants to pay her $1 million to lose her virginity on camera. Can you imagine?).
But to judge by the contestants in the second round of initial auditions, which aired last week in Britain, she's still a shoe-in to win the competition. The British press has unkindly implied she's already sold out by getting her hair done, as if looking tidy is a betrayal of her bedraggled spinster image, but I think that's unfair. The woman's finding herself at the business end of every major network's cameras on both sides of the Atlantic. Let her do a little long-delayed grooming. She's hardly dating models and dining at The Ivy, like Simon. If she keeps her hair frizzy and trots herself out in a housecoat, she'll be blamed for turning her frumpy image into schtick. She can't win.
She's still plenty frumpy, if that's what's important to the press. Then again, I thought it was her voice we liked. It's not a Cinderella story if we don't let her try on the ball gown.



Reader Comments (Page 1 of 9)
4-25-2009 @ 10:59PM
patrick said...
How come we couldn't download Susan's performance on itunes? I would have paid!
Reply
4-29-2009 @ 7:01PM
Kim said...
Patrick... Go to Limewire and you can download anything. Even her performance.
5-02-2009 @ 9:51AM
patricia ann moyer said...
What a voice.. We all have to remember ..Stop looking on the outside and see the beauty on the inside.
5-17-2009 @ 2:13PM
eloise said...
I agree....I would pay to have her voice recorded and available to me at home. Please, please, don't lose this beautiful voice because someone like Simon dropped the ball
4-26-2009 @ 12:14AM
Nancy Hamma said...
I feel Susan Boyle is a star about to see her dreams come true and she rightfully deserves it, and to get her hair done if she wants. It is none of anyones business but hers Is it? One question, Are we going to see her sing again, as a follow-up? I sure hope so.
Reply
4-29-2009 @ 2:40PM
Rebecca said...
I agree completely. I want to see her benefit the most from her gorgeous voice. If we don't hear her sing again on YouTube, I sure as heck want to buy a CD!
4-26-2009 @ 1:24AM
Great Grandma said...
The middle-aged & older crowd are in love with Susan's voice AND her decency, This gives hope that we still have nice ladies out there - and some can also sing like angels! She is a superb example to youth.
Reply
4-29-2009 @ 4:56PM
Judy Schwartz said...
To our generation, we had the unassuming voice of Kate Smith, who did not focus on glamour, just pleased the nation with her wonderful voice and personality. Good to hear decent songs again.
4-29-2009 @ 6:54PM
Gwendolyn said...
Her voice is like that of an angel. God blesses all his children
4-26-2009 @ 1:27AM
leslie said...
Susan is great the way she is! That's what makes people love her! And her voice? Well, it can't be beat! This women should have been the British Barabra Striestrain! I hope she makes its to the top and beyond!
She has our votes!
Leslie
Reply
4-29-2009 @ 6:51PM
Sam Danner said...
Leslie, you are right about what you said about Susan Boyle. I am sick of seeing young girls on the front of Tabloids at the checkout counter with of the affairs and sex. I am sick of drug addictions, and movie stars personnel problems and who is sleeping with who. Susan Boyle, a mIddle aged woman of the working class has shown the world of the Vanity of age. I am 56 years old and this woman puts many females half her age to shame. I do not care what she looks like or how simple she acts. She is a human being that can indeed sing.
4-26-2009 @ 3:43AM
Judy Brenneman said...
What a Magical Voice - sounds like an Angel from above.
Reply
4-29-2009 @ 4:05PM
MARGIE said...
I THINK SUSAN , WAS GREAT .I HOPE WE ALL CAN HEAR MORE FROM HER .JUNEGIRL08/
4-29-2009 @ 4:15PM
susan boil said...
i taoooooooootaly agreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee. tthaaaaaaaaaaaaaaannnnnnk you foooooooooooooooooor liiiiiiiiistenneeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeing
love your hope;less little chubby cheeked suasan boyle xoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxxo
4-27-2009 @ 5:59AM
brian said...
geez, no wonder the worlds so screwed up,this woman has a great voice and all you can think about is how much money everyone else missed out on!
Reply
4-26-2009 @ 9:06AM
Henry said...
The main reason Susan is so popular is her voice, not her looks. It is so refreshing to hear someone that can actually carry a tune and one can understand her words while singing. Last season on AGT there was a man that had one of the most beautiful voices I've heard in many, many years and the judges treated him like pond scum. He did come in 4th place but only because America voted him back on after the judges kicked him off. His name is Donald Braswell, few men nowadays can sing like an angel, but he can. His only problem is his looks. Unlike Susan, he is one of the best looking men to ever appear on any talent show. Simon Cowell is looking for screamers not talent. If the contestant has talent and isn't a looker he pushes them. God help the person like Braswell that has both, Simon kicks them to the curbe. I enjoyed Susan's video and hope she can hang in there, like Donald, she has a fantastic voice. Both have had hard times in their lives.
Reply
4-29-2009 @ 2:46PM
Kitty said...
omg you are right Simon isn't looking for folks who can sign he wants both the looks & the voice
4-29-2009 @ 2:56PM
Sue said...
What's wrong with Braswell's looks? I thought he was quite handsome. And the eventual winner, Neal E. Boyd, while having a beautiful voice, is no matinee idol. )I was rooting for Eli Mattson.)
4-29-2009 @ 3:00PM
Susanctuary78 said...
What was wrong with Donald Braswell's looks? I thought he was quite nice looking AND talented. I wouldn't go so far as to say they want looks AND talent; after all, Neal E. Boyd was the winner last year, and while he's got a wonderful voice, he's no matinee idol.
4-29-2009 @ 4:01PM
Jo Ann Sayers said...
AMEN to the coment! Who cares how they look. It's great to be able to hear words again, and beautiful voices, instead of screaming.