Skip to Content

Do sales make you happy? Why your good bargain high won't last

More
Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Shopping, Simplification

While reading The Ethical Executive by Robert Hoyk and Paul Hersey, one of the learnings that struck me most was that the happiness gained from very big achievements; such as getting a big raise or financial windfall, for instance; lasts, at most, three to six months. In many cases our happiness has returned to pre-achievement levels after only a few weeks.

So when I read the headline about bargains in today's Wall Street Journal, "Deals Abound, But Which Offer Lasting Delight?" I thought it would be an expose to the truth: delight doesn't last, especially if it's just about saving a few hundred dollars on a flat screen. Karen Blumenthal doesn't really touch on the lastingness of happiness, but more whether or not happiness (beyond the initial thrill of the deal) lasts at all.

According to the experts she consults for the piece, spending time with family and friends makes you far happier than the enormity (or relative price:value) of your material goods. She recommends that you, for instance, buy a home that's closer to work and friends' homes than one that's in a prestigious neighborhood; or a big-screen TV if it allows you to become closer to your children (hers encouraged her college-age daughters to come over and watch the Olympics at her house). I'd take this a little further, encouraging consumers not to buy anything simply for the satisfaction of the savings (even if it's something you actually want), and remind you that all this is just more evidence that shopping doesn't make you happy, not in the long term. Put away your credit cards and play chess with your children; go to a knitting or book group; join a craft circle; or just go for a long walk with someone you love. Your happiness may not always last a long time, but at least it didn't cost you anything.
Subscribe to Walletpop

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)

Neal's Yard Dairy: Farm Cheeses from the British Isles
Neal's Yard Dairy is a nominee for a Luxist Award for Best Cheese Shop. Neal's Yard Dairy was ...
Caviar House & Prunier: The Caviar Destination for Royalty
Nominated for a Luxist Award in the Best Caviar Retailer category is Caviar House & Prunier. ...

Amy Pyle
Amy Pyle Filed under: Banks, Budgets, Credit, Real Estate, Recession

Faces of loan modification: Christine Attalla, Bolingbrook, Ill.

How well is the government's loan modification working? WalletPop's four-part special report continues with profiles of some of those trying to get help. To read the overview, click here. Christine ...
Barbara Bartlein
Barbara Bartlein Filed under: Budgets, Debt, Home, Real Estate

Extreme home makeover, Part V: $55,000 later, we're finally done

This is the last of a five-part series about how the writer and her husband, Charlie, tackled a major overhaul of their home and the pitfalls they faced along the way. To read the first installment ...
Barbara Bartlein
Barbara Bartlein Filed under: Budgets, Home, Real Estate, Wealth, Recession

Extreme home makeover, Part IV: Progress at last, but roadblocks remain

This is the fourth part of a five-part series about how the writer and her husband, Charlie, tackled a major overhaul of their home and the pitfalls they faced along the way. To read the first ...
Kelly Phillips Erb
Kelly Phillips Erb Filed under: Tax, Technology, Taxes-income-tax-basics, Taxes-advice

E-filing tips that should save time, if not money

If the trend in e-filing continues, the IRS expects more than 100 million individual taxpayers to file their tax returns electronically for the 2009 tax year. More than one-third of those taxpayers ...

Headlines from WalletPop Partners