Now that 60 Minutes has made us afraid of recycling e-waste, where can we turn?
Filed under: Entrepreneurship, Shopping, Fraud
If you caught Sunday night's episode of 60 Minutes, you were treated to not just an incredible example of journalism but also a gripping story about what happens to the personal computers and laptops we recycle--it's a tale that apparently often ends in Guiyu, China where you can't breathe the air without hacking, and most of the children have lead coursing through their blood. That's because in Guiyu, workers are paid $8 a day to dismantle electronic waste, and they use chemicals to burn away the plastic to extract the metals lodged in the equipment. And during this process, lead, mercury and polyvinyl chloride are released, all of which are all cancer-causing agents.It was a great story, especially when CBS correspondent Scott Pelley confronted Brandon Richter, CEO of Executive Recycling in Englewood, Colorado. Richter had been interviewed, talking about the importance of safely recycling e-waste and his company's web site, according to 60 Minutes, had stressed that they never sent the laptops, monitors and other electronic equipment oversees. It was all done here in the United States (the web site makes no mention of that now).
At first, Richter came off as a very likable, earnest, honest CEO... and then, of course, later in the piece Pelley explains to Richter that they followed one of their containers of recycled e-waste to Hong Kong and then to Guiyu. The look on Richter's face... it was something to see. He had the fearful, haunted, destroyed look of a man who knows that he's going to doing some serious recycling and salvaging--that is, he's going to have to salvage his reputation.
But I bring this up not to dwell on this poor CEO. I do, however, feel bad for the people who, after the 60 Minutes episode aired, were left thinking, "Well, heck, where can we go to recycle our old computers?"
Plenty of people want to do the right thing and not put their electronic equipment in their trash and have it wind up in a landfill, and yet that's exactly what is happening--judging from the footage on 60 Minutes, Executive Recycling is only one of many recycling companies sending this equipment overseas. And so we're all left wondering who the good guys in e-waste recycling are, and since most consumers and personal finance writers don't have the budget of a 60 Minutes, it's not exactly easy to investigate any of them.
That said, if you want to recycle one of your computers, I'd suggest--based solely on their reputation--trying Costco. They have an e-waste recycling program, and I'd like to think that they recycle in a safe, ethical and legal manner.
They accept PCs, LCD monitors, digital cameras, camcorders, game systems and MP3 players. If you're giving away something that still has value, Costco will pay you for it with a cash card that you can use to make purchases within the store. And then if you buy a new TV at Costco--as I strain mightily to segue to an ending in this post--be sure to TiVO it to catch last Sunday's 60 Minutes episode when it runs again. And it will run again. That's one thing you can say about television. With all of its reruns, the television industry knows how to recycle.
Geoff Williams is a freelance journalist and the author of C.C. Pyle's Amazing Foot Race: The True Story of the 1928 Coast-to-Coast Run Across America (Rodale). And, hey, here's a P.S. to all of this, if you want to click onto another link. A producer from 60 Minutes contacted us with information on how you can determine if your recycling center is ethically recycling PC parts.



Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-11-2008 @ 2:27PM
DK, Los Angeles said...
Go to the group featured on the 60 Minutes Broadcast, Basel Action Network. They are a watchdog group named for the treaty that is supposed to stop rich countries from dumping toxic waste on poor ones. They run a program to certify ethical recyclers.
The following link provides a list of recommended organizations:
http://www.ban.org/pledge1.html
Reply
11-11-2008 @ 2:37PM
Eddie said...
I read this article under the impression that computer recyclers were extracting personel information that is sometimes left on the hard drives, even though it shows that there is nothing there at all, and this article would tell me how to avoid such a demise. That would be my biggest worry if I were to recycle my PC. Who the hell cares what they do in China?
Reply
11-14-2008 @ 4:40PM
Tammy said...
HEY EVERYBODY!! Eddie said let's dump, dump, DUMP our hazardous waste on other people! YAY!!
The point IS... to recycle! To reuse the plastic, metal, etc... not to let it sit in a trash heap, contaminate other parts of the world, and have little kids born with three heads. Just because it's in China, doesn't mean it doesn't effect us... LEAD is in the WATER supply... where do you think that water goes?? Into the oceans... into the fish, into the atmosphere... into plants... into animals... eventually it WILL make it's way to the other side of the planet. i.e. into YOUR drinking water and food. YUMMY!!
Also, the people that are TRYING to do the right thing were completely LIED to. They expect their televisions, computers, etc not to wind up in a landfill and it did anyway. NOT cool!!
With all the global warming going on... every little bit helps. So, when southern Georgia becomes beach front property, and the only place habitable will be Canada; you think you might take notice then?? Stop being ignorant and DO something!!
12-01-2008 @ 1:28PM
Sérgio Silva said...
Just before you recycle you should search for people who want to take them. join some groups at yahoo.com that freecycle! For those who don't know what that is ... it's like a mailing list where people accept old things and actually recicle by using them. I bet that are a lot of instituitions who can keep your old computer along with the CRT. The steps of disposing something (IT CAN BE ANYTHING) should be :
1) If the item is working, DON'T SEND IT TO RECYCLE. Try to give them to somebody else who is interested. DON'T TWROW ANYTHING THAT WORKS TO THE GARBAGE. THAT SHOULD BE A FELONY. Give it to your local school or community centers, they will be appreciated.
2) If the thing doesn't work check your local stores that accept this kind of material for gathering the good parts or try to fix it somehow.
3) Now you can think of sending it to some recycling center credited by some authority that you have some way to know what they do to your old stuff
4) Last thing : BUY LESS! You don't need all the things you have. STOP BUYING STUFF FOR PLEASURE OR JUST BECAUSE. WE ARE DESTROYING OUR WORLD DUE TO THIS KIND OF BEHAVIOUR. BE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE FUTURE OF YOUR KIDS AND ACT. Encourage or friends and family to do the same.
For Christmas time, yous friends or family members , your childs, they don't need all that stuff they are receiving this christmas. Make some movie with theirs baby pictures, burn it in a cd, use recycled paper to wrap it, and give it to your friend and family. Don't buy superfulous stuff just because. By a book, write a friendly or lovely note as a christmas gift ... use your imagination ... we have to consume less to become a sustainable world.
Check ...
www.storyofstuff.com
www.chrismartenson.com/crash-course
You can buy some of DVD's stated above because in the future you can show your kids and they can show your granchilds what change you made in their life. They can see what you were doing by acting like this and thank you for the space for change and prosperity that you provide them.
Reply