Skip to Content

Barbie won't settle for $100 million, wants complete destruction of Bratz

More
Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Entrepreneurship, Extracurriculars, Shopping

Girl fights can be so nasty. In the epic battle between Barbie and Bratz, the tall goddess doll appears to be winning. But the $100 million verdict in Barbie's favor in a copyright infringement case doesn't appear to be enough for parent company Mattel. In the latest legal wranglings, Mattel wants a judge to ban MGA Entertainment, the maker of the Bratz line, from making more Bratz dolls and also wants existing products impounded and destroyed. A judge won't decide the case until January, so holiday sales of Bratz items will not be affected.

Toy Wishes Hot Dozen

    Every year, Toy Wishes magazine names the "Hot Dozen" -- toys that the trade magazine predicts will be the hottest sellers that holiday season. On this year's list: Toy: Kota the Triceratops Manufacturer: Hasbro Playskool | Price: $300

    Hasbro / AP

    Toy: Ultimate Wall-E Manufacturer: Thinkway Toys | Price: $249.99

    Thinkway Toys / AP

    Toy: U-Dance Manufacturer: Hasbro | Price: $74.99

    Hasbro / AP

    Toy: Bakugan Battle Brawlers Manufacturer: Spin Master | Price: $12.99

    SPIN MASTER LTD / AP

    Toy: Disney Clickables Fairy Charms Starter Set Manufacturer: Techno Source | Price: $29.99

    Amazon.com

    Toy: Animal Scramble Manufacturer: Wild Planet | Price: $29.99

    Wild Planet / AP

    Toy: Bratz Really Rock! Jade Manufacturer: MGA Entertainment | Price: $19.99

    Amazon.com

    Toy: Crayola Glow Station Manufacturer: Crayola | Price: $29.99

    Crayola / AP

    Toy: Pacific Girl Gourmet Cupcake Maker Manufacturer: Jakks | Price: $29.99

    Amazon.com

    Toy: Lego Angents Mission 6: Mobile Command Center Manufacturer: Lego | Price: $89.99

    www.shop.lego.com



Can you hear millions of little girls around the country crying into their sippy cups? This is the result of the harsh world of branding -- you have to protect your products at all costs. Mattel, being the world's largest toymaker, has the most at stake and also the biggest war chest for carrying out a fight like this. But these sorts of battles play out across the business world every day at all sorts of levels, right down to one of your co-workers presenting one of your ideas as his own.

This particular case is probably more common that you'd think, given the millions involved. The dispute was over whether or not Bratz doll designer Carter Bryant came up with the concept for the dolls while he was working for Mattel, and then quit to make the dolls with another company. A federal jury found that this was the case. But the new wranglings are about whether or not MGA Entertainment can continue with the line, which has more than 40 characters and a ton of spin-off products. Is it only first-generation dolls, which spawned from Bryant's design? Or the whole she-bang? If Mattel wins, will county sheriff's be breaking into people's homes to collect their illegal dolls, or will they issue a lead-paint-style recall, where people are asked to destroy them?

It would seem, in cases like this, that the cat (or rather, the brat) is out of the bag. This is why these cases are so hard to settle and hinge on cash penalties. The same thing in going on at dozens of companies right now -- RIM Blackberry faces this dilemma, as does Vonage, to name just two -- and when the whole company's business is based on a "stolen" design, it can spell huge trouble.

Mattel has been so fierce in fighting this case because sales of rival Barbie dolls have slid since Bratz came on the scene in 2001, and were down 15% in 2007. Mattel as a whole isn't doing so great either, with the economy, toy recalls and other problems weighing down the company. It recently announced it was laying off 1,000 employees.
Subscribe to Walletpop

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 23)

How to Serve Cheese
Everyone loves cheese, but do you know how to compose a cheese plate? What cheeses go well ...
Too Many Sweets Will Impair Your Immunity
It doesn't matter what time of year it is, sugar and sweets always seem to be in abundance. Cookies, ...

Ron Dicker
Ron Dicker Filed under: Recession, Economizer

Welcome to the gold party craze: A new day pawning

Sometimes when Amber Watson-Tardiff comes across a single cuff-link or a massive tangle of chains in her jewelry box, it occurs to her that it might be time for a gold party. Like many people who ...
Aaron Crowe
Aaron Crowe Filed under: Saving Money, Shopping, Economizer

What to do with those unwanted Christmas gifts

The Christmas gifts have been unwrapped and all of the good stuff has been played with. And alone under a pile of wrapping paper sits the hideous sweater from a sweet aunt who doesn't know any better. ...
Laura Heller
Laura Heller Filed under: Shopping, Economizer

The best and worst return policies of the holiday season

Spending time with family is one thing, but spending a lifetime with that sweater your Aunt Emily gave you for Christmas is another. Before you head back to the mall with your unwanted items, there ...
Martha C. White
Martha C. White Filed under: Banks

Diet for fat-cat bankers an illusion

As another year of jobs lost, homes foreclosed and budgets cut draws to a close in America, some of Wall Street heftiest fat cats are tipping the scales with their bonuses -- and pocketing your tax ...

Headlines from WalletPop Partners