Borrowing against a 401(k): a very bad idea
Filed under: Budgets, Retire, Tax

As the threat of foreclosure continues to mount for many homeowners, the temptation to borrow against a 401(k) increases. Very bad idea, yet one that occurred to 13-19% more 401(k) holders in 2007. A recent article in CFO Magazine details a few of the ugly scenarios that can result.
Yes, many companies offer loan programs as part of their 401(k) programs as an incentive to get employees to participate. Employee loans against 401(k) balances are bad for both employers and employees. Not only is it a huge administrative headache for employers, but employees often get caught if their are any discrepancies or inaccuracies in the amortization schedule for repayment. Like the IRS will care that someone in the HR department made a mistake. The employee is solely responsible for any and all payback irregularities.
One of the advantages of participating in a 401(k) program is to take advantage of the free money from matching employer contributions as well as compound interest on contributions. Neither of these advantages occur when an employee stops making new contributions and merely repays the borrowed amount. Problems mount exponentially if an employee loses his or her job while owing money against the 401(k) balance. Just when the employee is most at financial risk, the outstanding amount must be repaid in full or the IRS will consider the loan or withdrawal as ordinary income and tax it accordingly. There is a 10% penalty if the borrower is under age 59 1/2.
The IRS does allow for hardship withdrawals from a 401(k) to avoid foreclosure of a primary residence, but the long term savings consequences are staggering. A 5 year, $8,200 loan can have a $62,000 impact on the 401(k) bottom line. Cutting expenses, renegotiating with creditors, getting a second job, are just a few of the much better alternatives for financially strapped homeowners.
Recent Posts
- Where the jobs will be: Obama's green energy economy and you (12/01/2008)
- New York busts shady tax preparers (12/01/2008)
- Why I'm holding on to my CostCo card (12/01/2008)
- Hold your noses: Economy slashes plastic surgeons' business (12/01/2008)
- Tax Tips: Potential break for retirees (12/01/2008)

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-03-2008 @ 3:47PM
UrbanFrugal said...
Borrowing against a 401K is a horrible idea! If you decide that you wanted to borrow against social security you wouldn't be allowed to do that. Investing for retirement only has its full effect if you invest and take advantage of compounding interest and returns from gains. Depleting the amount that you invested or saved robs you of the gains.
By paying penalties and taxes on early withdrawals you will have much less to look forward to spending in retirement.
http://www.urbanfrugal.com
Reply