Couple suing investment advisor for losing hundreds of thousands of dollars for them
Filed under: Ripoffs and Scams
Stephen David and his wife Linda sold a business and had $1 million from the sale to carry them through retirement and pay for college for their youngest child. They put their $1 million plus $500,000 of savings to work with investment broker Charles Moni, hoping to get about $150,000 a year out of their account. That would have meant they needed a 10% a year return on their money, yet they wanted to be conservative in their investments.
The investment account started losing money right away, and the Davises complained to the broker, who told them they'd regain their value. They took $625,000 out of their account and put it in a savings account for safekeeping. The broker put the remaining money in one stock: Rigel Pharmaceuticals.
In one day, the couple lost $450,000 in this stock. The couple has sued the broker, claiming that he put them in bad investments and traded excessively to net himself almost $200,000 in fees. Their losses total $680,000 plus the money they would have made on that balance if they had it to invest.
Yikes! Buyer beware... working with an investment advisor can be risky business. You really need to check out who you're working with. But most importantly, you need to be actively involved in the management of your money. You can't let an advisor just run off and do whatever he pleases with your money.
Give your broker very clear guidelines about what risks you're willing to take. When in doubt, be conservative. If a strategy or an investment sounds too risky and makes you uncomfortable, say no. You often can't ever recover from a devastating loss like this, especially if you're retirement age. Your number one concern should be protecting your money, and your investment advisor must be forced to respect that and play by your rules.
Tracy L. Coenen, CPA, MBA, CFE performs fraud examinations and financial investigations for her company Sequence Inc. Forensic Accounting, and is the author of Essentials of Corporate Fraud.
The investment account started losing money right away, and the Davises complained to the broker, who told them they'd regain their value. They took $625,000 out of their account and put it in a savings account for safekeeping. The broker put the remaining money in one stock: Rigel Pharmaceuticals.
In one day, the couple lost $450,000 in this stock. The couple has sued the broker, claiming that he put them in bad investments and traded excessively to net himself almost $200,000 in fees. Their losses total $680,000 plus the money they would have made on that balance if they had it to invest.
Yikes! Buyer beware... working with an investment advisor can be risky business. You really need to check out who you're working with. But most importantly, you need to be actively involved in the management of your money. You can't let an advisor just run off and do whatever he pleases with your money.
Give your broker very clear guidelines about what risks you're willing to take. When in doubt, be conservative. If a strategy or an investment sounds too risky and makes you uncomfortable, say no. You often can't ever recover from a devastating loss like this, especially if you're retirement age. Your number one concern should be protecting your money, and your investment advisor must be forced to respect that and play by your rules.
Tracy L. Coenen, CPA, MBA, CFE performs fraud examinations and financial investigations for her company Sequence Inc. Forensic Accounting, and is the author of Essentials of Corporate Fraud.
Recent Posts
- The Job Hunt: Under-employed numbers increasing (1/07/2009)
- Identity theft grows nearly 50% in 2008 (1/07/2009)
- Books for hard times (1/07/2009)
- New year, new sweepstakes at Dollar General (1/07/2009)
- Yes we can!...buy an Obama throw blanket and other trinkets, thanks to QVC and others (1/07/2009)

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
1-31-2008 @ 11:34AM
James said...
This broker needs to be digging ditches for folsum county prison!
Reply
1-31-2008 @ 1:12PM
Japippy said...
Wow: that is a real HORROR story. I learned very early on in life that Financial Advisors come in two categories: one whereby they are given Carte Blanche to do with people's money as they see fit and the other where they are merely advisors, and work for their clients on a rather small percentage basis which determines their annual fee based on the amount of money "MADE" for the client. Of course, if you give a broker carte blanche, he's going to do as many buys and sells as his fingers can type up for you in a day. It's called PURE GREED. But, on the other hand, if you are working on a percentage of earned basis, then you are most likely going to stay honest, and if you put your clients' money into a profitable investment which continues to make money for them, then that is where the money should stay and everyone will be happy. I hope stories like this make it all over the place to warn the unsuspecting investor that what those people allowed to happen; DOES; in fact happen way to frequently. I've had two very good friends who went the same route, because they didn't think they knew enough about the market to earn their own money. Unfortunately, one has lost well over half of his money, and the other had to file bankruptcy. It's really unfortunate for them that they wouldn't listen to me. But, the brokers that they were using, were far more convincing in telling them how GOOD he was/is than I was in telling them to watch out before they get burned.
Jim Petersen
Reply
1-31-2008 @ 2:09PM
John G said...
Ms. Coenen: I am not too familiar with this computer. Would you please send me an e-mail address so that I can e-mail you a letter, that I intend to send to my financial advisor's company?? John G
Reply